Difference between nier replicant and gestalt

After a long wait, NierR Replicant ver. Fans now playing the new NieR Replicant may not be aware of the major differences between this game and its variant, NieR Gestalt. NieR Replicant ver. It's more than a remaster of the original NieR, but it's also very true to the original and isn't considered a full-fledged remake.

Log In Sign Up. What do you need help on? Cancel X. Topic Archived. Sign Up for free or Log In if you already have an account to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts. I've beaten the game twice and i'm still a bit fuzzy on the details.

Difference between nier replicant and gestalt

This is not entirely accurate. Additionally, Father and Brother have different birthdays, but it was essentially a mistake that was overlooked:. The games also take place at different times and likely slightly different timelines, unconfirmed :. I believe this misconception stems from the lack of understanding the fundamental difference between translation and localization. There simply is no way to avoid this. There are generally two schools of thought behind what makes a good translation. Some people believe that a translation should stay as close to the the original source material as possible, including preserving sentence structure and phrasing even if it feels unnatural or clunky in the target language. I believe this notion comes from not fully understanding how things have to be localized for a specific target audience. Rudimentary knowledge of the original language can also lead to misinterpretations. Although I can understand the passion fans have for the original source material, I do think that some of these ideas are a little impractical. Additionally within the narrative, the MC is sometimes a father and sometimes a brother depending on when his Replicant perished and was reconstructed. I recently asked Yoko Taro if he was able to comment on whether or not there were any significant changes to the scripts between Gestalt and Replicant in this thread on Twitter:. Rekka: Sorry for the sudden question. To your best recollection, there is nothing significantly different between the two scripts, correct? Yoko: The scripts are roughly the same.

This was supposed to be more parallel to what Japanese gamers enjoyed seeing in their protagonists.

Log In Sign Up. What do you need help on? Cancel X. Topic Archived Page 1 of 2 Last. Sign Up for free or Log In if you already have an account to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts. Majutsuko 13 years ago 3. Yume nado

Now that Nier Replicant ver. Some people might be surprised that it doesn't seem to be the same game they played way back in Both games are near identical, but a few small changes in the game really stand out. Square Enix decided to bring Nier Replicant back leaving Gestalt in the past. This decision might leave players wondering what was up with the first two Nier games. When Nier was released in , the version players could get depended on what hardware they had. Nier Replicant was technically the original version of the game. The developers didn't intend for there to be two versions. However, the suits at Square Enix thought the sales abroad would be lackluster and pressured them to make a retconned Western version called Nier Gestalt in order to appease Western audiences. The original Nier Replicant was never released outside of Japan at least, not until the remake.

Difference between nier replicant and gestalt

Despite the absurd subtitle, NieR Replicant might confuse some fans, as the game wasn't called that when it originally released in the West. The upcoming remaster is specifically NeiR Replicant , and it brings together the same team that worked on the critically-acclaimed NieR: Automata. For anyone wondering what the differences in Replicant might be, here's an explanation of everything. In all honestly, the differences between NieR Replicant and Gestalt are fairly minor. The main difference has to do with the main character, named NieR , and their relationship with Yonah. In Replicant Nier is a young teenage man and Yonah is his sister, but in Gestalt Nier is am an in his 40s with a daughter named Yonah.

Xome property

In Gestalt, they have a father-daughter relationship. Topic Archived Page 1 of 2 Last. Sign Up for free or Log In if you already have an account to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts. Or maybe I'm just daft. In the original game, it felt rather clunky and outdated when compared to action-adventure games like Devil May Cry and Bayonetta. You guys with the "incestuous undertones" are bloody retarded and sick. Thankfully, this remastered version caters to that audience too. For many fans, Automata is their introduction to the series and now thanks to this remaster and the considerable changes they have many reasons to dive into NieR: Replicant. Log In Sign Up. Curiously, both protagonists are named Nier despite technically being different characters. He was more typical of what is found in a lot of JRPGs. In addition, the framerate runs at a silky smooth 60fps meaning that gamers will get a much more fluid and responsive experience. However, the character models have definitely seen a visual upgrade and characters like Kaine are able to display more emotional range than ever before. The frazzled, middle-aged beefcake in Nier Gestalt is a reflection of what the Japanese thought Westerners wanted to see in a protagonist. That was one of the reasons why PlatinumGames were brought on board to create a better game on a mechanical level.

Yet, for players that stuck with it, they found a game that told a deep and emotional story that hit home with many players. Furthermore, this was and still is a game that merged genres like bullet hell shooters, Resident Evil- style adventuring, and more. This was improved and polished to near perfection in the sequel NieR: Automata and helped the series reach a bigger audience.

However, the suits at Square Enix thought the sales abroad would be lackluster and pressured them to make a retconned Western version called Nier Gestalt in order to appease Western audiences. If Replicant is incestuous, so is Gestalt. It's hard to say. Outside of the different main characters, the two versions of NieR are practically the same game. NieR Replicant was released in Japan and had a much younger protagonist with a small frame, and Gestalt's version of Nier was a bulked-up man in his 40s. Perhaps Square Enix was preparing Gestalt to be a Western release, or maybe not. As Iori stated, you play as Nier, Yonah's brother. As for the overall purpose of the scene, the details matter very little. How do you get indigo moonflower seeds? Not everyone is able to donate their time to a largely implausible cause. With popular games like God of War topping the charts in the West, it was assumed that Western fans would prefer a more powerful-looking lead character. Replicant and Gestalt are actually two versions of the exact same game, released in different regions and on different platforms. That said, each variant is different, and fans often do prefer one or the other. Rudimentary knowledge of the original language can also lead to misinterpretations. Would brother Nier sacrifice himself for Kaine?