Openhab vs home assistant

From my Point of View, openhab ist much better in configuration of UIs. If you Invest enough time you can get really beautiful visualization. What other advantages so you see for openhab?

Hi all! I use homeassistant since I feel quite good to use it but I want to try something of new and also if is possible avoid to use the home assistant cloud that is not free! In my system I have:. Most of us fall into one of the following categories:. All I know is that many people use it happily, which means it must have some good features and qualities. The same goes for openHAB.

Openhab vs home assistant

OpenHab is a Home Automation Hub based on open source. It was developed in Java and the OpenHab community is considered to be well established and helpful by the masses. Home Automation Systems like OpenHab perform different functions in terms of your smart devices like monitoring and controlling their activities to get the desired result. It provides the users with add-ons that give OpenHab various capabilities and the ability to interact. The configuration process will take anywhere from 20 to 30 minutes of your time. The entire process is listed on the OpenHab website where one can follow the installation guide and configure the hub properly. A stable internet connection is always recommended for a smooth configuration experience. The paper and the Web UI from the latest version of the OpenHab allow the users to perform several configuration processes without needing to edit the files but the paper UI seldom supports all the other features in the OpenHab. Hence, users are expected to edit files to achieve the configuration. OpenHab updates are complex and time-consuming as compared to the Home Assistant as the updates require a command line to get the updates as Add ON. OpenHab with a smart hub can integrate all devices.

Supervisor and the shutdown server controls moved and confused me just recently as guides and videos do not match what the UI looks like today… If your wanting a project that has less breaking changes as changes are discussed and reviewed in more depth before being made then openHAB may be for you. Both platforms showed impressive offering, with OpenHAB being more mature and stable, openhab vs home assistant Home Assistant more innovative and flexible platform to control your smart devices We have selected Home Assistant as the overall winner.

I find it quite amusing that HA that is written in Python is more qumbersome than openHAB written in java wrt writing rules in Python via habapp. And I have learned to hate java thru the years… As I probably have became a grumpy old man, I DO really like configuration in. Configuration that ends up in. It is completely useless to compare HA and OH in detail, because when two do the same thing, it is not the same thing after all, everyone will use the most suitable automation for their own case. This was a change to deliberately avoid a breaking change between 3. HA has Google fit integration. In Openhab i wrote a python script that should be launched in the exact Moment when im on the scale and send over mqtt… But no idea how to read Blood pressure and Heart rate….

So best bet is to spin new OH in lxc in proxmox on different ip. Same influx or whatever you are using, then try what will not work and continue from there. Something similar I did in Docker. It took less than a month, not intensive daily work. I used a simple script, which simply downloaded the new version, unpacked it, copied all configuration and copied the bindings to the correct folder there was no UI yet , so an update went in about 4 minutes, including stopping the running service, changing the links automatically and restarting the service. In the unlikely event of a failing update, I simply relinked to the old version.

Openhab vs home assistant

I was thinking about move to Home Assistant, but after I installed, setup a few integration and started to use, I have some doubts. What do you think? I find mainui too hard and time consuming for me, but I do have one mainui interface a photo frame. We need more people to contribute to OH, and as discussed before, that means OH needs to attract more new users. If it works it works.

Two bedroom house for rent

Home Assistant is free and open-source software that allows users allows users to add and control various smart home devices. However, the level of compatibility and flexibility can vary depending on the device and the platform. The Home Assistant app begins with various capabilities that OpenHAB does not have, the first of which is location tracking. It could be due to the lack of documentation and you can certainly get bindings working, but the process of setting up things, models, items, and pages seems more rigid than the customization that Home Assistant provides. Need more help? Home Assistant formely Hass. But as mentioned above please consider donating to the foundation which buys the hardware to host the cloud and pay for running costs and more. Home Assistant has a large library of official and community-contributed integrations for various devices and services, which makes it easy to connect and control smart devices using the platform. While openHABian offers a streamlined and simplified way to get up and running quickly, it is a complete openHAB home automation system capable of automating your entire home. J-N-K Jan N. But the biggest advantage is the rule system where you have full control about nearly everything. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. Add-ons give openHAB a wide array of capabilities, from User Interfaces to the ability to interact with a large and growing number of physical Things. Currently, it claims to support devices from different manufacturers.

OpenHab is a Home Automation Hub based on open source. It was developed in Java and the OpenHab community is considered to be well established and helpful by the masses.

If you have a battery powered device and send a command the value in HA will always be that of the command and not the actual state. The default view is the automatically created a view that showing all the devices and automation you have configured. More advanced users can customize the interface completely with some advanced visual features that we have not even seen in the professional systems. Android users can use excellent official Android application. Anything we say about them is biased by virtue of coming from a group of people who primarily use openHAB, no matter how objective we try to be. Home Assistant acts like a server or brain, it stores device status information, sends and receives instructions, edits advanced scenes, etc. Reply to Memes. Learn More. The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. If no one wants it, then I could just use a script or two and be done and move onto something else.